How to Expedite Prosecution Before the Chinese Patent Office
Aug 02 2021
- Posted By: Thomas A. Miller
Chinese patent protection has become a very important component of a worldwide intellectual property portfolio. Considering China only began granting patent rights in 1984, while the United States has been doing so since 1790, this has been an absolute sea change in business planning for many global companies over the past few decades. In the last year alone, a total of 1.49 million patent applications were filed with the National Intellectual Property Administration, PRC (the Chinese Patent & Trademark Office). By comparison, this is more than were filed with the United States Patent & Trademark Office and European Patent Office combined.
In such an inundated system, it stands to reason that the backlog and resulting wait times before the Chinese Patent Office until examination can be substantial. For example, patent applicants can often wait over a year after filing until receiving a first substantive examination from a Chinese Examiner, with an overall pendency in excess of two years between filing to final disposition not being uncommon.
With some industries, where products have a relatively long shelf life between design changes, such waits can be palatable. However, with fast-paced industries where redesigns are yearly, if not seasonal, such as consumer goods, electronics, and software, the viability of the product may well be gone or least on a significant ebb by the time the patent issues.
It is with these concerns in mind, that this article is written. In the paragraphs that follow, we will attempt to identify the various ways to expedite the prosecution of your patent application before the Chinese Patent Office. In many ways, they are not dissimilar from the Track One Expedited Prosecution, or other accelerated prosecution procedures before the US Patent & Trademark Office. However, knowing the acceleration options at your disposal, the types of patent protection afforded by the Chinese Patent Office, and the timing required for implementation of each are key.
Patent Prosecution Highway
U.S. patent applicants will be familiar with the Patent Prosecution Highway (PPH). Generally speaking, the PPH is a set of international agreements which state that if a patent claim has been granted in one national patent office on an invention, the examination and allowance of that claim should serve to expedite its prosecution in other national patent offices rather than reinventing the wheel as it were. If a request for participation in the PPH is granted, the pendency of the Chinese patent application will be reduced by an average of one Office Action and thus several months.
China is party to PPH agreements with many countries including the United States. Accordingly, if a patent claim has been allowed in any IP5 program, namely, the national patent offices of Japan, South Korea, China, Europe, and the U.S., that allowance can help expedite prosecution of your patent application before the Chinese Patent Office. The specific requirements to take advantage of the PPH in China are:
- The Chinese patent application must have the same priority date as the IP5 application serving as the basis for the PPH request;
- At least one claim of the priority application must be allowed;
- All claims of the Chinese patent application must substantially correspond to the allowed priority claim; and
- The Chinese patent application must be published (be more than 18 months past the priority date), but not yet been substantively examined.
Should all the foregoing elements be met, Applicants should consider enlisting in the PPH with the Chinese Patent Office. To do so, the Applicant will need to provide copies of all Office Actions from the priority application, copies of all prior art from the priority application, and a table showing correspondence between the pending Chinese claims and the allowed claims of the priority application. There is no official fee associated with the PPH request.
Similar to certain acceleration provisions before the USPTO, in some situations it is possible to expedite prosecution of a Chinese patent application based on real-world developments. For example, if a particular invention is directed to certain technologies, or is actively being infringed, or is of particular national or public interest, that patent application can be examined out of turn. The particular requirements for prioritized examination are:
- The invention must relate to key national industries such as energy, the internet, big data, cloud computing or other fields where products quickly become outdated;
- The invention must be currently being used with evidence that others are doing the same;
- The application must have first been filed in China and then another country.
If the above criteria are met, the prioritized examination request should be filed with the Chinese Patent Office, along with all known prior art. One nuance is that the approval of the IP Office in the particular Chinese state or province involved must also be submitted. For U.S. applicants, the Chinese counsel with whom your U.S. patent counsel interfaces can provide that approval.
Should the request be granted, the Chinese Patent Office will examine and issue a first Office Action within 45 days, with examination being completed within one year of the request.
One often overlooked option to always keep in mind is the actual request for examination. Applicants for Chinese patent protection have up to 36 months from filing to request substantive examination. If not done at filing, the full 36 months is the default. Sometimes this is advantageous as U.S. filers may wish to see how prosecution before the U.S. Patent Office (or other foreign jurisdiction) plays out before deciding whether to proceed with, and thus expend funds for, the Chinese prosecution. However, in other situations where the market and viability of the technology are known, Applicants would be wise to simply file the request for examination upon filing.
Depending on the facts of your given situations, options exist for expediting a patent application before the Chinese Patent Office, even when facing their mountainous backlog of pending cases. Should you find yourself in need of a fast resolution to your Chinese application, please do not hesitate to contact one of the patent attorneys at von Briesen & Roper, s.c. We are well experienced with U.S. and international patent practice and would be happy to help.
 In 2020, a total of 646,244 patent applications were filed with the United States Patent & Trademark Office, while a total of 181,532 patent applications were filed with the European Patent Office (not including those filed with the individual patent offices of each of the thirty-eight member states to the EPO.)
von Briesen Legal Update is a periodic publication of von Briesen & Roper, s.c. It is intended for general information purposes for the community and highlights recent changes and developments in the legal area. This publication does not constitute legal advice, and the reader should consult legal counsel to determine how this information applies to any specific situation.